Start with oven depth, not thickness
The Baking Steel Pro and Plus solve different space problems. The Pro is a 16" x 16" square, 3/8-inch thick, 27-pound plate built for full 16-inch NY-style pizzas. The Plus is a 15" x 20" rectangle, 1/4-inch thick, 22 pounds, built to bake four sourdough loaves at once or two 12-inch pizzas side by side.
Measure your oven rack from front to back before comparing anything else. The Pro needs 18 inches or more of rack depth; most ovens are 18–20 inches deep, so it fits with room to spare. The Plus is 20 inches deep, so its long side demands a deeper rack. If your oven is smaller, the Pro's square footprint may be the safer fit even though it is thicker.
The two steels in their own dimensions
- Baking Steel Pro: Baking Steel Pro: 16" x 16" x 3/8", 27 pounds, solid carbon steel, pre-seasoned; max pizza size 16 inches. The square shape and 16-inch capacity make it the choice for full-size NY-style pies, but the 27-pound weight and 3/8-inch thickness demand a sturdy rack and a deep oven.

Baking Steel Pro - Baking Steel Plus: Baking Steel Plus: 15" x 20" x 1/4", 22 pounds, solid carbon steel, pre-seasoned; capacity for 4 sourdough loaves or 2 large pizzas at once. The rectangular shape trades maximum pizza diameter for batch bread baking and side-by-side pizzas, while the 1/4-inch thickness keeps it lighter.

Baking Steel Plus
Thickness changes preheat time and heat retention
Thickness is not a quality score; it is a trade between preheat patience and heat recovery. The Pro's 3/8-inch carbon steel is 50% thicker than the Original and requires 60–75 minutes at 500–550°F. The Plus, at 1/4 inch, is the same thickness as the Original, which preheats in about 45 minutes. If you want pizza on a weeknight without a long oven warm-up, the Plus gets there sooner. If you open the oven door to launch a 16-inch pie and want the deck to stay hot, the Pro's extra mass is the reason to wait.
- Baking Steel Pro: 3/8-inch thick; preheat 60–75 minutes at 500–550°F; bake 16-inch pizzas in 5–7 minutes.
- Baking Steel Plus: 1/4-inch thick; same thickness as the Original, which preheats in about 45 minutes; bakes two 12-inch pizzas side by side in 5–7 minutes.
Pizza size versus bread capacity
Choose the Pro if your goal is a restaurant-size 16-inch NY-style pizza. Its 16-inch square surface matches the largest pizza most pizzerias sell, and the 3/8-inch steel is built to hold heat through that launch. The tradeoff is that a standard 14-inch peel is too small to launch and retrieve a 16-inch pizza, so you will need a 16-inch peel.
Choose the Plus if you bake bread in batches or cook for a crowd. It bakes four sourdough loaves at once with open baking, no Dutch oven and no heavy lid to remove mid-bake. It also fits two 12-inch pizzas side by side, which is more useful for a pizza party than one larger pie if your guests are happy with 12-inch slices. The Plus cannot match the Pro's 16-inch pizza diameter, and the Pro cannot match the Plus's four-loaf capacity.
Weight, peel and stovetop use
- Lifting and storing: The Pro weighs 27 pounds; the Plus weighs 22 pounds. Both are pre-seasoned and ready to use, but both are heavy enough that you should plan a permanent or semi-permanent spot rather than moving them daily.
- Peel compatibility: The Pro's 16-inch pizzas require a 16-inch peel; a 14-inch peel is too small. The Plus's two 12-inch pizzas fit on a standard 14-inch peel, though you will launch them one at a time.
- Stovetop and grill: Both steels are compatible with oven, grill, gas stovetop, electric stovetop and induction cooktop. Flip either one over for smashburgers, pancakes or quesadillas when it is not baking pizza.
A simple decision rule
If your oven rack is at least 18 inches deep and your priority is the largest possible NY-style pizza with maximum heat retention, buy the Baking Steel Pro. Budget for a 16-inch peel at the same time.
If your oven rack is at least 20 inches deep and your priority is baking four loaves at once or two 12-inch pizzas side by side, buy the Baking Steel Plus. It preheats faster and weighs less, which matters if you will move it between oven and stovetop.
If your oven is shallower than 18 inches, neither steel is confirmed to fit by the supplied information; measure carefully before ordering, and consider a smaller steel from the lineup rather than forcing either of these.
Care and compatibility shared by both
- Baking Steel Pro: After the Pro cools, wipe it with a damp cloth, dry thoroughly and apply a light coat of oil. Never put it in the dishwasher. The Pro's care is simple but non-negotiable; dishwasher exposure is explicitly ruled out.
- Baking Steel Plus: The Plus follows the same cool-wipe-dry-oil routine and should never go in the dishwasher. It is made from food-grade carbon steel with no coatings, chemicals or non-stick surfaces. The Plus needs the same minimal care, and its bare carbon steel surface is why seasoning and drying matter.


